We've scanned every flight from Fort Myers to New York to find the best deals. If you want a cheap flight, it's best to be as flexible as you can on dates. If that day's no good for you, try searching by month to see some alternative dates.
You can use the filters on your search to see more flights and find cheaper rates – New York has more than one airport. So if you don't need to fly into New York La Guardia Airport, it's worth checking your other options. The 1743 km flight usually takes about 5 hrs 35 mins.
If you're planning on going to New York during this time, you could take a look at other airport options. Or you could try to get a last-minute bargain.